Best Story-Driven RPGs to Play If You Love Mass Effect
There are few gaming experiences quite like finishing a great story-driven RPG. You spend hours exploring unfamiliar worlds, making difficult decisions, getting attached to characters and becoming invested in a story that stays with you long after the credits roll. If you’re searching for the best story-driven RPGs to play if you love Mass Effect, there are some fantastic adventures worth adding to your library.
For many of us, the original Mass Effect trilogy set a ridiculously high standard. It wasn’t simply about saving the galaxy. It was about the people you brought along for the ride. The conversations aboard the Normandy, the arguments between squadmates, the loyalty missions, the romances and those decisions that could come back to haunt you two games later all helped make the experience special.
And let’s be honest: sometimes you finish a game like that and immediately wonder what on earth you’re supposed to play next.
The good news is that there are plenty of RPGs offering excellent storytelling, memorable characters and meaningful choices. They might not recreate the exact magic of BioWare’s space opera, but several come surprisingly close in their own ways.
Whether you’re looking for another brilliant cast of companions, a world shaped by your decisions or a gripping science-fiction adventure, here are some of the best story-driven RPGs worth playing.
What Makes a Great Story-Driven RPG?
Before jumping into the recommendations, it’s worth looking at what makes these games so enjoyable in the first place.
A brilliant RPG isn’t necessarily the one with the biggest map, the most quests or hundreds of hours of content. Those things can certainly help, but they don’t mean much if the characters are forgettable or the story gives you little reason to care.
For me, the strongest story-driven RPGs tend to get a few important things right:
Memorable characters: Companions should feel like actual people, with their own personalities, motivations, histories and flaws.
Meaningful choices: Decisions should have consequences, whether they affect a relationship, a quest, a faction or the wider story.
Strong worldbuilding: The setting should feel believable and interesting enough that you want to explore every corner of it.
Emotional storytelling: Great games make you laugh, think, celebrate and occasionally question why the developers have decided to hurt you.
Player investment: You should feel like you’re shaping the adventure rather than simply following a sequence of events.
Not every game needs to tick every box. Some deliver incredible character development, while others excel at worldbuilding or giving players freedom over their decisions.
The following games listed below as the Best story-driven RPGs each offer something different, but they all have something important in common: they give you a reason to care about the journey.
1. Baldur's Gate 3 – For Unforgettable Companions and Meaningful Choices
Developer: Larian Studios
Best for: Deep companion stories, player freedom and branching narratives
Baldur’s Gate 3 is one of the strongest recommendations in this Best story-driven RPGs list for anyone who loves character-driven RPGs. It takes the familiar fantasy setting of Dungeons & Dragons and builds an enormous adventure around player choice, relationships and the consequences of your actions.
The first thing you’ll notice is just how much freedom the game gives you. There are countless ways to approach situations, conversations can take unexpected turns, and decisions can have consequences you might not see coming until much later.
However, one of its biggest strengths is its companions.
Characters such as Shadowheart, Astarion, Gale and Lae’zel have their own personalities, beliefs and personal struggles. They don’t simply exist to fill a space in your party. They react to your decisions, disagree with you, develop relationships and have personal stories that become increasingly important as the adventure unfolds.
That sense of travelling alongside a group of individuals with their own motivations is something Mass Effect fans will recognise.
The major difference is the combat. Instead of Mass Effect’s real-time third-person shooting, Baldur’s Gate 3 uses turn-based tactical combat based on Dungeons & Dragons rules. It’s a very different experience, but one that rewards planning and creative thinking.
Why Mass Effect fans should play it: If your favourite part of Mass Effect was building relationships with your crew, learning their stories and watching your decisions influence the adventure, Baldur’s Gate 3 is an excellent place to start.
2. Cyberpunk 2077 – For Cinematic Storytelling and Emotional Characters
Developer: CD Projekt Red
Best for: Immersive science fiction, character-driven quests and a memorable world
If you’re looking for another science-fiction RPG, Cyberpunk 2077 deserves a serious look.
Set in the sprawling metropolis of Night City, the game puts you in the shoes of V, a mercenary trying to survive in a world dominated by corporations, technology, crime and desperation.
Night City is one of the game’s biggest strengths. It’s a fascinating setting filled with different communities, competing interests and characters who all have their own reasons for doing what they do.
But what makes Cyberpunk 2077 particularly special is its storytelling.
The main narrative explores identity, mortality, ambition, and what it means to remain human in a world where technology can fundamentally change the body and mind. Along the way, you’ll meet characters whose personal stories can be just as compelling as the main plot.
Johnny Silverhand is an especially important part of that experience. The relationship between V and Johnny gives the story much of its personality, creating a dynamic that develops throughout the adventure.
It’s also worth exploring the side quests rather than rushing through the main story. Some of the most memorable moments in Cyberpunk 2077 happen away from the central narrative.
There is one important difference for Mass Effect fans: Cyberpunk 2077 is built around a central protagonist rather than a traditional squad of recruitable companions travelling with you throughout the game. You won’t be assembling a Normandy-style crew, but you will meet characters with meaningful personal stories and relationships.
Why Mass Effect fans should play it: If you loved the science-fiction setting, cinematic storytelling and emotional character moments of Mass Effect, Cyberpunk 2077 offers a different but equally absorbing kind of futuristic adventure and why it makes it to this list of Best story-driven RPGs.
3. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt – For Worldbuilding and Difficult Decisions
Developer: CD Projekt Red
Best for: Rich storytelling, memorable quests and morally complicated choices
There is a reason The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt continues to be mentioned whenever people discuss the greatest story-driven RPGs.
You play as Geralt of Rivia, a professional monster hunter searching for Ciri, a young woman with a powerful connection to his past. What begins as a personal search gradually becomes an enormous adventure involving political conflicts, dangerous creatures and some seriously complicated decisions.
One of the game’s greatest achievements is its writing.
The world feels lived in, and even relatively small quests can develop into surprisingly emotional stories. Characters aren’t always good or evil, and the decisions you make rarely come with an obvious right answer.
Sometimes you’ll be forced to choose between two unpleasant outcomes. Other times, you’ll make a decision believing you’ve done the right thing, only to discover the consequences much later.
The game also does an excellent job of making its supporting characters memorable. Geralt’s relationships with characters such as Yennefer, Triss and Ciri give the main story much of its emotional weight.
Combat and exploration are very different from Mass Effect, and you’re playing an established character rather than creating your own commander. However, if you enjoy getting lost in a detailed world with excellent quests and strong writing, The Witcher 3 is difficult to ignore.
Why Mass Effect fans should play it: If you enjoy complex characters, difficult moral decisions and stories that aren’t afraid to challenge you, The Witcher 3 delivers all three in abundance.
4. Dragon Age: Origins – Classic BioWare at Its Best
Developer: BioWare
Best for: Classic BioWare storytelling, companion relationships and consequential decisions
Now we’re getting into familiar territory.
If you’ve played Mass Effect and want to experience another example of the kind of storytelling that helped establish BioWare’s reputation, Dragon Age: Origins should be near the top of your list.
Released in 2009, this fantasy RPG follows a group of heroes attempting to stop a devastating threat known as the Blight. You play as a Grey Warden, a member of an order tasked with fighting the monstrous Darkspawn.
What makes Origins so special is the way it approaches character development and player choice.
You can choose from different origins for your character, each providing a unique introduction to the world and its conflicts. Your decisions throughout the adventure can influence relationships, political alliances and the fate of important characters.
And then there’s the party.
Characters such as Alistair, Morrigan, Leliana and Sten bring plenty of personality to the adventure. They have their own opinions, beliefs and motivations, and they won’t always agree with your decisions.
Sound familiar?
The companion interactions are one of the game’s biggest strengths. Conversations around camp help develop relationships and reveal more about the people travelling alongside you. Some characters will challenge your decisions, while others may become loyal friends or something more.
The combat and presentation are definitely products of their time. It’s an older RPG, and players accustomed to modern action combat may need a little patience. However, the quality of the writing and the strength of its characters have aged remarkably well.
For anyone who misses the character-driven storytelling of classic BioWare, this is essential playing.
Why Mass Effect fans should play it: Dragon Age: Origins offers much of the companion-focused storytelling, difficult decisions and party relationships that made the original Mass Effect trilogy so memorable, just in a darker fantasy setting.
5. The Outer Worlds – For a Smaller Science-Fiction Adventure
Developer: Obsidian Entertainment
Best for: Science-fiction exploration, faction choices, and a healthy dose of humour
If you’re after another science-fiction RPG but don’t necessarily want to commit to an enormous open-world adventure, The Outer Worlds is worth considering.
Set in a corporate-controlled colony on the edge of space, the game follows a character who wakes from cryosleep and becomes caught up in a conflict involving powerful corporations, settlements and competing factions.
The setting is colourful, often ridiculous and packed with satire. Corporate slogans, questionable business practices and characters who have somehow managed to make a terrible situation even worse give the game a distinctive personality.
But underneath the humour is a role-playing adventure where your decisions can influence the people and communities you encounter.
You’ll recruit companions, explore different locations and make choices that affect quests and faction relationships. The game also gives you plenty of opportunities to approach situations through dialogue rather than simply shooting your way through every problem.
It isn’t quite the same scale as Mass Effect, and its first-person perspective makes combat feel very different. Its companion system is also more limited than the Normandy’s extensive crew relationships.
Still, it captures something enjoyable about travelling through a science-fiction universe, meeting unusual characters and deciding what kind of person you want to be.
Why Mass Effect fans should play it: If you want another space-based RPG with interesting factions, companion characters, and plenty of player choice, The Outer Worlds is a fun change of pace and definitely deserves to be here as Best story-driven RPGs.
6. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic – For Classic Space Opera
Developer: BioWare
Best for: Classic BioWare storytelling, space opera and moral choices
It would feel wrong to put together a list like this without mentioning Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
Often referred to as KOTOR, this classic RPG was developed by BioWare and released in 2003. It takes place thousands of years before the events of the main Star Wars films, allowing the developers to explore a different period in the galaxy’s history.
If you enjoy Mass Effect’s science-fiction setting, memorable companions and decisions that shape your character, KOTOR has plenty to offer.
You’ll explore different planets, recruit companions and become involved in a story that gradually expands into something much bigger. Your decisions can influence your character’s moral direction, and the game gives you plenty of opportunities to decide how you want to approach the adventure.
The companions are another highlight. Each brings their own personality and background, helping the journey feel like more than a series of disconnected missions.
Of course, this is an older game. Its visuals, interface and combat systems may feel dated compared with modern RPGs. But if you can look beyond those limitations, there’s a reason it remains such a beloved part of BioWare’s history.
Why Mass Effect fans should play it: KOTOR offers a classic BioWare space adventure with companions, moral decisions and a strong central story. If you want to experience another piece of the studio’s RPG history, this is an excellent choice.
Which Story-Driven RPG Should Mass Effect Fans Play First?
The best game for you depends on what you loved most about Mass Effect.
Some players want another brilliant group of companions. Others want a science-fiction setting, difficult decisions or a story that keeps them invested for dozens of hours.
Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide.
| If you loved this part of Mass Effect… | Try this game |
|---|---|
| Companion relationships and meaningful choices | Baldur’s Gate 3 |
| Science-fiction storytelling and emotional character arcs | Cyberpunk 2077 |
| Difficult decisions and incredible worldbuilding | The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt |
| Classic BioWare companion storytelling | Dragon Age: Origins |
| Space exploration, factions and humour | The Outer Worlds |
| Classic BioWare science-fiction and moral choices | Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic |
There isn’t one perfect replacement for Mass Effect. Each of these games captures a different part of what makes a great RPG, and that’s probably the best way to approach the list.
If I had to recommend a starting point, I’d look at Baldur’s Gate 3 for its companion relationships and player choice, Dragon Age: Origins for classic BioWare storytelling, or Cyberpunk 2077 if you want to stay in a futuristic setting.
Final Thoughts: Great RPGs Are About the People You Meet Along the Way
One of the reasons Mass Effect remains so memorable is that its story isn’t just about saving the galaxy. It’s about the people you meet along the way and the relationships you build with them.
It’s the conversations aboard the Normandy. The loyalty missions. The arguments between squadmates. The decisions that seemed small at the time but eventually changed everything.
Those are the moments that turn a good RPG into something genuinely special.
The games on this list might approach storytelling differently, but they all offer something worth experiencing. Whether you’re exploring Night City, travelling through Thedas, making questionable decisions in Faerûn or heading into the unknown with a crew of unlikely companions, there’s no shortage of brilliant adventures waiting to be discovered.
And if you’ve already played all six, there’s always another RPG out there waiting to surprise you.
What about you? Which story-driven RPG would you recommend to a Mass Effect fan? Are there any games we’ve missed that deserve a place on this list? Let us know in the comments. We’re always looking for another adventure worth getting lost in.
GhettoSmurf Gaming is all about gaming news, reviews, guides and discussions for players who love getting stuck into great games. If you’ve enjoyed this list, explore more of our gaming content and let us know which RPG we should cover next.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the best story-driven RPG to play after Mass Effect?
Baldur’s Gate 3 is an excellent choice for players who enjoy companion relationships, branching narratives and meaningful decisions. Dragon Age: Origins is another strong option for anyone who wants classic BioWare storytelling in a fantasy setting.
2. What games are most similar to Mass Effect?
Games such as The Outer Worlds, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic and Dragon Age: Origins share several qualities with Mass Effect, including companion characters, player choices and story-driven role-playing. None recreates the complete Mass Effect experience, but each offers something familiar.
3. Which RPG has the best companion characters?
Baldur’s Gate 3 is particularly strong when it comes to companion personalities, personal quests and relationships. Dragon Age: Origins is also an excellent choice, especially for players who enjoy classic BioWare party interactions.
4. Are there any good science-fiction RPGs like Mass Effect?
Cyberpunk 2077 and The Outer Worlds are two worthwhile options. Both offer science-fiction settings and character-driven storytelling, although their gameplay structures and approaches to companions are quite different from Mass Effect.
5. Is Dragon Age: Origins still worth playing?
Absolutely. Although its graphics, interface and combat systems feel older than modern RPGs, Dragon Age: Origins remains a fantastic experience thanks to its writing, companions, worldbuilding and meaningful decisions.
Best Story-Driven RPGs to Play If You Love Mass Effect
Finished Mass Effect and looking for your next great RPG?...
Read MoreSAVE MASS EFFECT — EA HAS CANCELLED OUR FUTURE, BUT THE FANS AREN’T GIVING UP
Mass Effect has given players unforgettable characters, stories and memories....
Read MoreWORLD OF WARCRAFT RETAIL: MY LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP WITH AZEROTH
I've played Warcraft for almost half my life. From discovering...
Read More